Rule7 Forums
Home       Members    Calendar    Who's On
Welcome Guest ( Login | Register )
        


««12345»»»

Vegans Expand / Collapse
Author
Message
Posted Thursday, May 03, 2007 1:20 PM


Wag

WagWagWagWagWagWagWagWag

Group: Basic Members
Last Login: Today @ 3:57 PM
Posts: 1,040, Visits: 8,197
Hang on Balor if it’s ok to keep a pet based on the theory that animals have been domesticated for so long and it would be cruel to just leave them uncared for, surely one could extend the theory to dairy cows, sheep(wool), chickens(eggs) etc?

_____________________________________________________

RL: Mr Sofar

Curved core weaponry and bespoke stuff.

ShelfordFX
Post #28915
Posted Thursday, May 03, 2007 2:02 PM


and Minimeister

and Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeister

Group: Basic Members
Last Login: Sunday, April 06, 2008 8:31 AM
Posts: 960, Visits: 1,402
Shelford (5/3/2007)
Hang on Balor if it’s ok to keep a pet based on the theory that animals have been domesticated for so long and it would be cruel to just leave them uncared for, surely one could extend the theory to dairy cows, sheep(wool), chickens(eggs) etc?

Seems fair to me.  That's (one of the reasons) why I don't eat meat or by products of slaughter.  I'm also quite happy and about the only thing I can be said to miss are:

a) fish fingers

and

b) Those little Bernard Matthew's mini kievs.

So, all told, I eat more healthily now.  Anyway, I could never be vegan because I'd never be able to drink mead again.  The horror!


There is only overconfidence and terror.
Post #28926
Posted Thursday, May 03, 2007 2:13 PM


Wag

WagWagWagWagWagWagWagWag

Group: Basic Members
Last Login: Today @ 3:57 PM
Posts: 1,040, Visits: 8,197
‘why I don't eat meat or by products of slaughter’

But Coffmeister dairy cows, sheep(wool), chickens(eggs) do all get the chop at the end of their productive lives. So isn’t that just as cruel as breeding them to be slaughtered for meat?

_____________________________________________________

RL: Mr Sofar

Curved core weaponry and bespoke stuff.

ShelfordFX

Post #28927
Posted Thursday, May 03, 2007 2:30 PM


Wag

WagWagWagWagWagWagWagWag

Group: Basic Members
Last Login: Thursday, July 17, 2008 1:03 PM
Posts: 1,084, Visits: 934
coffmeister (5/3/2007)
Hmm... but dogs can survive on a vegetarian diet and cats can't.  (Which is just as well, or we'd never hear the end of it).  I agree that you shouldn't just feed dogs corn.  It means that they don't taste as nice when you eat them.

Vegan diet is a voluntary life style chosen by the particpators of their own free will for a range of reasons.

Forcing such a diet on a non-willing participant especially one that is designed to hunt and kill on such a basic level it still exhibits those traits even after years of domestication is unethical and as Shelford points out an abuse of the right to freedom that many Vegans demand is central to animal rights. Dogs want to eat meat give me a bloody hunk of cow and a potatoe and we'll see which one the dogs prefer,,,

Doing it to Cats you should be shot for.

Post #28929
Posted Thursday, May 03, 2007 2:31 PM


Wag

WagWagWagWagWagWagWagWag

Group: Basic Members
Last Login: Thursday, July 17, 2008 1:03 PM
Posts: 1,084, Visits: 934
Shelford (5/3/2007)
‘why I don't eat meat or by products of slaughter’

But Coffmeister dairy cows, sheep(wool), chickens(eggs) do all get the chop at the end of their productive lives. So isn’t that just as cruel as breeding them to be slaughtered for meat?

 

Arguably it is far more evil since its a tacit refusal to utilise the entirity of an animal you probably use for other produce not to mention leather. Which is wasteful and shows a lack of respect for life.

Post #28931
Posted Thursday, May 03, 2007 2:32 PM


Wag

WagWagWagWagWagWagWagWag

Group: System Moderators
Last Login: Tuesday, July 15, 2008 10:07 PM
Posts: 1,140, Visits: 3,624
Yes, that is the argument. If we had not bred these animals specifically for these purposes then they would not exist - certainly not in the forms they do now which are largely helpless in the wild.

I am saying this is one argument, not that it is particularly one I find appealing

However, to completely doom all domestic animals to extinction, everyone would have to become vegetarian or vegan and I don't think even the most optimistic vegetarian or vegan would expect that to be a reality. Not even the mad cow, avian flu and salmonella scares (which have done a hell of a lot to convince some to change diet) persuaded everyone that meat was bad for you. Countless studies on carconogenic properties of meat have likewise had little impact.

I personally think that everyone has a right to eat as they wish and the current way of thinking allows this to be so. You are rarely laughed at or condemned for being a vegan these days. You can eat in restaurants without people giving you strange looks because of some 'Californian fad'. At least you can in this country now... I think you get tarred and feathered in France for even looking like a vegan

The only thing I say to vegetarians is that you do have to be extra careful about certain nutrients. You have to make sure that you are getting enough nutrition in your diet. Most sensible veggies I know do know this and take care. The ones I worry about are the ones who simply take an ordinary meal (meat and two veg) and just remove the meat and think that is healthy.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Whispering God is your friend... trust the Whispering God...

Ruins of Empire

1st - 3rd Feb, 2008, Gladstone scout centre, Chester

Post #28932
Posted Thursday, May 03, 2007 3:34 PM


and Minimeister

and Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeisterand Minimeister

Group: Basic Members
Last Login: Sunday, April 06, 2008 8:31 AM
Posts: 960, Visits: 1,402
Flannel (5/3/2007)
Shelford (5/3/2007)
‘why I don't eat meat or by products of slaughter’

But Coffmeister dairy cows, sheep(wool), chickens(eggs) do all get the chop at the end of their productive lives. So isn’t that just as cruel as breeding them to be slaughtered for meat?

 Arguably it is far more evil since its a tacit refusal to utilise the entirity of an animal you probably use for other produce not to mention leather. Which is wasteful and shows a lack of respect for life.

Eating meat is not good for you, nor has it been a source of joy to me.  I now eat better than I did when I wasn't.  I don't want to eat gelatine (ground up cow and big bones) because I find it all fairly disgusting.  If you want to eat it, that's fine, but I don't.  So deal.  Please note the emphasis above.

As for leather?  I generally try and avoid it, but character's need armour and metal's too expensive. 

Something that may give you food for thought:  I made the decision to not eat meat or fish in 1999 and then in 2000 I stopped eating gelatine containing products.  I'm still relatively unfussy about cheese (although I find the way whey is made fairly horrific) but am choosing "vegetarian" whenever I can.

So, according to the arguments on this board, if I couldn't change to a completely healthy and great meat free lifestyle, _straight_ away in 1999, then I shouldn't bother even trying and would be a massive hypocrite for even thinking about it.

Grow up.


There is only overconfidence and terror.
Post #28942
Posted Thursday, May 03, 2007 3:44 PM


Wag

WagWagWagWagWagWagWagWag

Group: Basic Members
Last Login: Today @ 3:57 PM
Posts: 1,040, Visits: 8,197
Hey sorry Peter/Coffmeister, I jumped to the conclusion (wrongly) that you had chosen to become a Veggie based on ethical grounds not health grounds.

I feel all grown up! I was only asking a question.

_____________________________________________________

RL: Mr Sofar

Curved core weaponry and bespoke stuff.

ShelfordFX

Post #28945